SUMMARY
Suggestopedia
has undergone a variety of changes over the two decades of its existence.
Some changes, mainly those to the concert session, were made by Lozanov
himself, others were made by exponents adapting the method for their own
environment. The latest version of the suggestopedic cycle includes a
preparation session, decoding of the materials to be learnt, an active
and a passive concert session in which materials are read with the backing
of entire classical or baroque pieces respectively, and extensive review
and elaboration sessions.
In Eastern
Europe the method differs the least fom this model and it is still referred
to as Suggestopedia. Researchers in the German Democratic Republic,
however, have reduced the two concert sessions to one and made changes
to Lozanov's music selection. Music from the baroque period which is still
predominant in Lozanov's selection is no longer used in the GDR as a result
of research which showed more favourable student responses for the Vienna
classical period.
The two major
versions of Suggestopedia in the West are Superlearning and
SALT, both originating in North America. Another version developed
by a linguist in West Germany is called Psychopädie. The originators
of these versions have also made changes to Lozanov's Suggestopedia.
The chief contribution of Superlearning is the inclusion
of synchronisation of breathing and presentation of words during the passive
concert session. The limited research does not consistently show this
element to have a positive effect on the retention of materials. However,
the literature suggests consistently that this element may be cumbersome
for the students to handle which is reflected in the fact that synchronisation
has been dropped by most practitioners. Superlearning also advocated
self-study courses produced on audio-tapes, a system which was adopted
by commercial enterprises around the world. Although good examples of
such courses exist, vital elements such as the teacher's presence, group
dynamics and the communicative interaction between students cannot be
included in such courses.
The most important
contribution of SALT is the inclusion of mind-calming during the
presentation phase. Although research, here too, is not extensive, the
literature shows a positive trend towards improved learning and improved
behaviour as well as other positive psychological effects being associated
with mind-calming. This may therefore well be a positive addition to Suggestopedia
which is reflected in the fact that most Western practitioners have
adopted mind-calming in their programme.
The contribution
of Psychopädie to Suggestopedia is the insertion of a reproductive
phase before the concert sessions. The rationale for this was to break
up the long passive states in which suggestopedic students in intensive
courses find themselves. Although there is no empirical evidence as yet
which supports the efficacy of such a phase, it may well be attractive
to students and teachers alike to have a more balanced programme in terms
of students' arousal level. Some practitioners already use this phase
in their programme, most notably the GDR researchers.
Although there
are distinct differences between the four versions of Accelerative
Learning discussed in this chapter, caution must be exercised when
interpreting research results if the treatment is not described in detail.
Labels are sometimes used interchangeably, and elements generally associated
with a particular version may no longer be used. This has led to some
confusion about the exact content of an Accelerative Learning course.
However, all four versions consistently use the same three elements. These
are music, relaxation and suggestion. While in the West special attention
is given to relaxation in the form of progressive relaxation or mind-calming
either during the preparation phase or before the concert session, practitioners
in the East no longer practice relaxation explicitly. According to Lozanov
(1978), however, relaxation is still produced through other suggestive
means, such as music, teacher behaviour and classroom atmosphere.
Since music,
relaxation and suggestion are also used in most other adaptations of Suggestopedia
not discussed here, we can assume that these elements are generally
seen as the most important in the approach. The presumed effects of these
elements will therefore be discussed in detail in the next chapter.
|